Careers18 min readLast checked

Best Country for Internationally Trained Doctors: UK vs Ireland vs Germany vs USA, Compared on Official Figures

Clunic Research Team

Category
Careers
Read time
18 min read
Sources
41 cited

Which is the best country for internationally trained doctors?

None of the four wins on every measure, and any page that gives the UK, Ireland, Germany and the USA a single score out of ten has had to choose weights that suit someone other than you. What can be compared is what each regulator, exam body and government publishes: the route, the exam, the fees, the waiting times, the language, the visa and the pay scale. This post sets those side by side for a doctor whose primary medical degree is from outside the EU, the EEA and the UK, and says where a figure is missing rather than filling the gap.

What does the comparison look like in one table?

UKIrelandGermanyUSA
LicenceGMC registration with a licence to practiseMedical Council registration, General DivisionApprobation from a state authorityState licence after ECFMG certification and residency
Main examPLAB 1 and 2PRES, unless exemptFachsprachprüfung and KenntnisprüfungUSMLE Steps 1, 2 CK and 3
Official fees, first-time passes£2,124 with the visa€1,067 to €2,919, plus a €1,000 permit€1,600 to €2,250 in four states, plus visa fees$5,905 to the end of Step 3
Working languageEnglishEnglishGermanEnglish
Can you skip postgraduate training?Yes, service posts are openYes, service posts are openYes, after ApprobationOnly in states with new pathways
Starting basic pay£41,226 a year, FY1, England€47,127 a year, intern€5,722.05 a month, gross table$69,106 to $84,579 a year, PGY-1 at four hospitals

Every figure in that table is explained, with its source, in the sections below. The pay row in particular cannot be read across: it mixes basic pay, a monthly gross table and institutional stipends, in three currencies.

What changed as of November 2026?

Four dated changes make older comparison pages wrong. As of November 2026: USMLE registration for international graduates has run through FSMB rather than ECFMG since 12 January 2026 (USMLE notice); Germany has made the Kenntnisprüfung the default for non-EU doctors for applications filed from 1 November 2026 (Federal Law Gazette); the HSE consolidated scales rose on 1 June 2026; and the NHS resident doctor scales for 2026/27 apply from 1 April 2026 under Pay and Conditions Circular (M&D) 1/2026 R2. In the USA, NRMP reported that 56.4% of non-US citizen international graduates matched in 2026, the lowest rate in five years.

Why compare these four countries?

They are the four destinations Clunic covers, they all recruit doctors trained abroad, and three of them work in English. Nurses weighing the same four countries have their own version of this comparison: the best country for international nurses.

How does a foreign doctor get licensed in the UK, Ireland, Germany and the USA?

The four systems differ less in difficulty than in shape. Two of them (the UK and Ireland) offer several doors into one national register. Germany has one route run by 16 state authorities. The USA has one route that passes through a competitive training match before any licence is issued.

How does the UK route work?

The GMC gives an international medical graduate five ways to show knowledge and skills: PLAB, an acceptable postgraduate qualification such as MRCP(UK) or MRCS awarded within three years, sponsorship by a royal college or approved sponsor, passes in the US, Canadian or Australian licensing exams, or the portfolio pathway for specialists. After that comes English evidence, ECFMG verification of the primary qualification and an application for full registration with a licence to practise. One register covers England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. The detail is on our page on working as a doctor in the UK.

How does the Irish route work?

A non-EEA graduate registers in the General Division through one of several sub-routes. Doctors whose internship was done in Australia, Malaysia, Malta, New Zealand, Pakistan, South Africa, Sudan or the UK use the Certificate of Experience route (Medical Council list). Doctors with a recognised higher qualification such as MRCP or MRCPI use the Higher Qualification route. Everyone else sits the PRES unless an exemption applies. Every route starts with EPIC verification and a Certificate of Good Standing from each regulator of the past five years. See doctors in Ireland.

How does the German route work?

A third-country doctor applies for the Approbation [licence to practise] to the authority of the state where they live or intend to work. The fixed parts are German at B2, the C1-oriented medical language exam, proof of medical knowledge and personal requirements such as a certificate of good conduct. Since 1 November 2026 knowledge is proved by default through the Kenntnisprüfung, with a four-week window to opt for a binding document review instead. Our guide for doctors in Germany walks through each step.

How does the US route work?

ECFMG certification (Steps 1 and 2 CK, OET Medicine, a Pathway and a verified diploma), then a residency place won through the NRMP Match, then a J-1 or H-1B visa, then Step 3 and a state licence. Seniority abroad does not shorten residency on the standard route: Cleveland Clinic states that trainees start at the entry level of their programme regardless of prior training (Cleveland Clinic GME). The full sequence is on doctors in the USA.

Which licensing exam does each country set, and how many pass?

The exams test different things, and only two of the four publish pass rates that apply to international candidates.

PLAB (UK)PRES (Ireland)Kenntnisprüfung (Germany)USMLE (USA)
PartsPLAB 1, 180 single best answer questions; PLAB 2, 16 clinical scenariosLevel 2, three-hour MCQ; Level 3, 12-station OSCE plus data paperPatient case and 60 to 90 minute oral and practical exam, in GermanStep 1, Step 2 CK, Step 3
WherePLAB 1 abroad, PLAB 2 in ManchesterLevel 2 in Dublin or Dubai, Level 3 in IrelandThe state that handles your fileSteps 1 and 2 CK can be taken outside the US and Canada for a region fee
Attempts4 at each part3 at each level within two years3 in total4 per Step
Published pass rate62.2% PLAB 1 and 59.8% PLAB 2 in 2025Not publishedNot published nationally75% first-time Step 1 pass, non-US schools, 2025
ResultAbout 6 weeks for PLAB 1About 6 weeksPass or fail, no scoreStep 1 pass or fail; Step 2 CK scored, minimum 218

Sources: GMC pass rates, Medical Council registration rules, German licensing regulations as amended in 2026 and USMLE performance data.

Is PLAB easier than the USMLE?

The published numbers do not answer that. PLAB rates are for all 2025 candidates, the USMLE figure is for first-time Step 1 takers from non-US schools, and the populations self-select differently. What can be said is structural: PLAB is two exams that lead straight to registration, while passing the USMLE leads only to the right to compete in the Match.

Is the German exam harder because it is in German?

It is the only one of the four that is conducted in a language most applicants learned as adults. The Fachsprachprüfung tests language only, not medicine, and the Kenntnisprüfung then tests internal medicine, surgery and further areas in German, with at most four candidates per session. Neither exam has an equivalent abroad.

Where does an exam not decide the outcome?

In the USA the decisive filter is the Match, not the exam. In Ireland, a doctor on the Certificate of Experience or Higher Qualification route sits no exam at all, and the decisive factor is the Council's processing queue.

Does an exam passed for one country count in another?

This is where most comparison pages are silent, and where a doctor can save a year. Credit runs in some directions and not others.

Exam already passedUK (GMC)Ireland (Medical Council)GermanyUSA
PLAB 2Leads to registrationReplaces the whole PRESNo creditNo credit
PLAB 1 onlyHalf of PLABReplaces PRES Level 2No creditNo credit
USMLE Steps 1 and 2 CKPart of the overseas exam route, which requires US licensing exam passes with no part attempted more than four timesReplace PRES Level 2, if passed within seven yearsNo creditRequired for ECFMG certification
PRESNot recognisedLeads to registrationNo creditNo credit
MRCP(UK) or MRCSAcceptable postgraduate qualification if awarded within three yearsCan support the Higher Qualification routeNo creditNo credit

Sources: Medical Council exemptions, GMC acceptable postgraduate qualifications and the PRES page, which records that the GMC does not recognise PRES Level 2 or Level 3.

Why does PLAB keep more doors open?

A PLAB 2 pass gives UK eligibility and also exempts the doctor from the whole Irish exam. The reverse is not true: a PRES pass counts for nothing with the GMC. For a doctor undecided between the two English-speaking European options, PLAB is the exam that keeps both open. Our post on what to do after passing PLAB 2 covers the UK side.

What does a USMLE holder gain outside the USA?

Steps 1 and 2 CK cut the Irish exam to its clinical half, and US licensing exam passes are one of the GMC's accepted alternatives to PLAB, subject to the attempt rule above. A doctor who matched poorly in the USA therefore has a shorter path to Ireland or the UK than to Germany.

Why does nothing transfer to Germany?

The German licensing law offers no exemption on the basis of foreign licensing exams. A doctor with PLAB, PRES or USMLE passes starts the German route at the same point as one without them, with the language exam.

How much does it cost to get licensed as a doctor in each country?

These totals add only fees the bodies themselves publish, for a doctor who passes everything at the first attempt. Each is in the currency the body charges, and we have not converted them, because a conversion rate is not an official figure.

What does the UK charge?

ItemFee
PLAB 1£283
PLAB 2£1,036
GMC full registration with a licence to practise£481
Health and Care Worker visa, up to 3 years£324
Total£2,124

£283 + £1,036 + £481 = £1,800 to the GMC, plus £324 = £2,124 (GMC fees, gov.uk visa fees). A doctor on the postgraduate qualification or sponsorship route skips PLAB: £481 + £324 = £805. There is no Immigration Health Surcharge on this visa.

What does Ireland charge?

ItemPRES exemptBoth PRES levels
Application, General Division€451€451
PRES Level 2None€352
PRES Level 3None€1,500
First full year of registration€616€616
Council subtotal€1,067€2,919
Critical Skills Employment Permit€1,000€1,000
Total€2,067€3,919

€451 + €616 = €1,067; adding €352 + €1,500 gives €2,919 (Medical Council fees). The €1,000 permit fee is from DETE; where the employer applies, it may not recover the fee from the doctor, and 90% is refunded if the application is refused.

What does Germany charge?

StateApprobationFachsprachprüfungKenntnisprüfungSum
Baden-Württemberg€450€420€1,100€1,970
Bavaria€400 to €500€550Up to €1,200Up to €2,250
North Rhine-Westphalia (Westfalen-Lippe)€150 to €700€400€1,050€1,600 to €2,150
Lower Saxony€100 to €600€595€980€1,675 to €2,175

For Baden-Württemberg, €450 + €420 + €1,100 = €1,970. Add the €75 national visa and up to €100 for a residence permit issued in Germany (Make it in Germany), and the Baden-Württemberg total is up to €2,145. Fee sources by state are listed on the Kenntnisprüfung page; the per-attempt range is €980 to €1,350 where published (Landesärztekammer Hessen).

What does the USA charge?

ItemFeeRunning total
MyIntealth account$110$110
ECFMG certification application$580$690
Credential verification$220$910
Step 1 with region fee abroad$905$1,815
Step 2 CK with region fee abroad$930$2,745
Pathway application$945$3,690
ERAS token, 30 programmes, transcript$585$4,275
NRMP registration$85$4,360
J-1 sponsorship plus SEVIS$590$4,950
Step 3$955$5,905

The $585 line is $185 + (30 × $11) + $70. Sources: ECFMG fees, USMLE fees and NRMP. Each additional programme beyond 30 in one specialty costs $30.

What is left out of every total?

English or German tests and courses, EPIC or ECFMG verification fees for the UK and Irish routes, translations, travel to PLAB 2 in Manchester, PRES Level 3 in Ireland or US interviews, and living costs during waits. No body publishes those as one figure, so we do not add them.

How long does it take to start work as a doctor in each country?

Only Ireland publishes processing times by route, and only Baden-Württemberg publishes an average for the whole German procedure. The UK and the USA publish times for individual steps.

CountryPublished timePublisher
UKECFMG verification: most institutions respond within 90 days. PLAB 1 results about 6 weeks. GMC decision: not published as one figure. Visa: usually within 3 weeksGMC, gov.uk
Ireland21 weeks (PRES route), 25 weeks (Higher Qualification), 51 to 53 weeks (Certificate of Experience), from a complete file. Permit: apply at least 12 weeks before the start dateMedical Council, DETE
GermanyLanguage exam wait about 4 to 6 months; knowledge exam wait about 8 to 10 months; completed procedures took about 3 years on average in the past yearRegierungspräsidium Stuttgart
USAOne Match a year: results in March for training that starts around July. 2027 Pathway documents due by 31 January 2027NRMP, ECFMG

What is the shortest published sequence in Ireland?

For a PRES candidate the Irish profession page adds the published pieces: about 6 weeks for each of two results, 21 weeks of processing and 12 weeks of permit lead time come to 6 + 6 + 21 + 12 = 45 weeks, before any wait for an exam date. The Council's times page also notes that Certificate of Experience applications have been slower than normal.

Why is the German average so long?

The three-year average from Baden-Württemberg reflects the old document-first system, including equivalence reports that could take up to 15 months. The new exam-first default aims to shorten it, and the law's target is an exam date within six months of the application. Whether that target is met will only show in future published averages. Our post on the new Kenntnisprüfung rule explains the change.

Why is there no UK or US end-to-end figure?

In the UK the variables are PLAB 2 seats, the speed of your medical school's response to ECFMG and your job search. In the USA the calendar is fixed by the annual Match, so a doctor who misses one cycle waits a year for the next. We do not invent a total for either.

What English or German level do doctors need in each country?

The regulator's language bar is usually higher than the immigration bar. Both apply.

CountryRegulator requirementImmigration requirement
UKIELTS Academic 7.5 overall and 7.0 in each area, or OET Medicine grade B in all four areasCEFR B2 for new Health and Care Worker applicants
IrelandIELTS Academic 7.0 overall and 6.5 in each module, or OET Medicine grade B in each module, within two yearsNo separate test stated for the Critical Skills permit in the sources we read
GermanyGerman B2, then the Fachsprachprüfung oriented to C1A2 for a recognition partnership; varies by residence title
USAOET Medicine: 350 in Listening, Reading and Speaking, 300 in Writing, for ECFMG certificationNot a separate licensing test

Sources: GMC, gov.uk, Medical Council, Landesärztekammer Baden-Württemberg, Make it in Germany and ECFMG.

Is the GMC bar higher than Ireland's?

On IELTS, yes: the GMC asks for 7.5 overall and 7.0 per area, against Ireland's 7.0 overall and 6.5 per module. On OET both ask for grade B in each part. A doctor whose IELTS is 7.0 overall meets the Irish standard but not the UK one.

Do native English speakers need the US test?

ECFMG states there are no exceptions for native English speakers. Every applicant for certification needs OET Medicine at the scores above.

How long does German take?

No authority publishes a typical time to reach B2 or C1, so we do not give one. What is published is that Baden-Württemberg asks applicants not to file before they hold B2, and that the Fachsprachprüfung costs €400 to €650 per attempt (Landesärztekammer Hessen).

Which visa do doctors use in the UK, Ireland, Germany and the USA?

These summaries are taken from government and sponsor pages. Clunic does not give immigration advice; immigration advice must come from a regulated adviser or lawyer in the country concerned.

UKIrelandGermanyUSA
RouteHealth and Care Worker visaCritical Skills Employment PermitQualification-measure permit, then EU Blue CardJ-1 (ECFMG sponsor) or H-1B (hospital petitions)
Fee to the doctor£324 up to 3 years, £628 longer€1,000, may be paid by the employer€75 visa, up to €100 permit$370 to ECFMG plus $220 SEVIS for J-1
Pay threshold£25,000 or the going rate€40,904, or the public pay agreement rate€45,934.20 for bottleneck professions in 2026Not applicable to J-1
Health surchargeNoneNot statedNot statedNot stated
LaterMay apply to settle after 5 yearsStamp 4 on completing the permitBlue Card after ApprobationJ-1: two-year home residence rule unless waived

Sources: gov.uk, DETE, Make it in Germany, ECFMG J-1 sponsorship.

Which visa is cheapest?

Germany's published fees are lowest at €75 plus up to €100. The UK visa is £324 with no healthcare surcharge, against £819 plus a surcharge usually £1,035 a year on the ordinary Skilled Worker route. In Ireland the €1,000 permit is often an employer cost.

What is unsettled in the USA?

USCIS states that certain H-1B petitions for workers outside the USA filed from 21 September 2025 must carry an additional $100,000 payment, that a federal court vacated the implementing guidance on 8 June 2026, and that the government intends to collect if that order is lifted. The Conrad 30 waiver for J-1 doctors depends on Congress extending it for those who took J-1 status on or after 1 October 2025. NRMP reported a 2026 match rate of 54.4% for international graduates needing visa sponsorship against 67.9% for those not needing it (NRMP).

Which visa needs no job first?

Only Germany has a published route to enter before a job: a residence permit for qualification measures under section 16d of the Residence Act, up to 24 months and extendable to three years, with secondary work of up to 20 hours a week. The other three tie the visa to a job offer or training post.

What do newly licensed doctors earn in each country?

Each figure below is from the scale its publisher sets, with the basis stated. They are starting points for the grade a new international doctor is likely to enter, not offers.

CountryGradePublished figureBasis and yearSource
UK (England)Foundation Year 1£41,226 a yearBasic pay, 40 hours, 2026/27NHS Employers circular 1/2026 R2
UK (England)Specialty doctor, first point£63,696 a yearBasic pay, 2026/27NHS Employers
IrelandIntern€47,127 a yearBasic, HSE consolidated scales from 1 June 2026HSE
IrelandSenior house officer€55,292 to €75,623 a yearBasic, 7 points, from 1 June 2026HSE
GermanyGroup I doctor, municipal hospital€5,722.05 a monthGross table, 40 hours, TV-Ärzte/VKA from 1 June 2026Marburger Bund
GermanyÄ1 doctor, university hospital€5,792.90 a monthGross table, 40 hours, TV-Ärzte (TdL) from 1 April 2026TdL
USAPGY-1 resident$69,106 to $84,579 a yearInstitutional stipends, Cleveland Clinic and Mass General Brigham, 2026Hospital GME pages

What does a German monthly figure come to over a year?

Twelve times the monthly table: €5,722.05 × 12 = €68,664.60, and €5,792.90 × 12 = €69,514.80. That is the table salary only, before on-call pay and night or weekend supplements, and it says nothing about any further annual payment the agreement may set.

What do the four US hospitals pay a first-year resident?

HospitalPGY-1Basis
Mayo Clinic$75,105Graduate Level 1, from 11 March 2026
Cleveland Clinic$69,106Grad Level 1, from 16 May 2026
Johns Hopkins$76,264Emergency medicine, 2026-2027
Mass General Brigham$84,579Housestaff scale from 1 July 2026

Our pages on Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinic cover how they recruit. There is no national resident scale in the USA, so these four are examples, not a range for the country.

What about pay after training?

Consultant basic pay in England runs £113,565 to £150,569 in 2026/27. Irish consultants on the 2023 contract are paid €238,221 to €286,151 from 1 June 2026. A German Ä2 specialist at a university hospital starts at €7,645.72 a month. The Bureau of Labor Statistics put the median wage for US physicians and surgeons at $275,930 in May 2025, a median of all employed physicians, not a scale.

Why can't you rank doctors' pay across the four countries?

Because the published figures measure different things, and turning them into one ranking would mean inventing the adjustments.

Are the bases the same?

No. The NHS and HSE figures are annual basic salaries. The German figures are monthly gross table salaries. The US figures are institutional stipends for trainees, and the BLS figure is a median of everyone in the occupation. Basic pay excludes the on-call, night and weekend payments that all four systems add, and those depend on the rota, which no regulator publishes.

Do the figures cover the whole country?

Not in the UK: the NHS circular is for England, and Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland publish their own values. In Germany, private, church and some university hospitals use other agreements. In the USA each institution sets its own stipend. Only the Irish HSE scales are national for public hospitals.

Is the starting grade the same?

Not necessarily. Many international doctors in the UK start in locally employed posts such as clinical fellow or trust grade, and the NHS circular states that trusts are not required to use national values for those. A doctor who was a specialist at home may enter the UK at specialty doctor level, Ireland at registrar level, Germany in the first group, and the USA at PGY-1 regardless of experience.

What about tax and living costs?

All figures are before tax, pension contributions and social insurance, which differ by country and personal situation. We do not publish a net figure or a cost-of-living adjustment, because none of the primary sources does.

Is a currency conversion fair?

A conversion picks a date and a rate that the bodies did not set, and it still leaves the differences above. That is why this post, like the nurses comparison, gives no score.

Which country suits which doctor?

Without a score, the useful question is which route your current documents make shortest. These follow from the published rules above.

A recent graduate with an internship and good English?

The UK, through PLAB: a known exam, four sittings of PLAB 1 a year, a £2,124 fee total and no surcharge. Large trusts such as Guy's and St Thomas' and Addenbrooke's publish their international hiring routes. Ireland is the alternative if your internship is on the Council's list.

A specialist with years of consultant-level experience?

The UK portfolio pathway to the Specialist Register costs £1,974. Ireland's Category E specialist assessment costs €4,086 and has a published time of 14 to 18 weeks. In Germany, specialist training and its exam are run by the state medical chamber once you hold the Approbation. The USA has no general shortcut, except in the states that FSMB lists as having enacted non-residency pathways: 25 plus Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands as of October 2026 (FSMB chart).

A doctor who already holds USMLE passes?

Ireland gives the most credit, replacing PRES Level 2 with Steps 1 and 2 CK, and the UK accepts US licensing exam passes under its overseas exam route. Both avoid the Match.

A doctor who speaks German or will learn it?

Germany has the lowest official fees, no cap on places and a route to work under a temporary permit [Berufserlaubnis] for up to two years while waiting (Bundesärzteordnung, section 10). The cost is time: language to B2 and C1 and exam waits that run to months. Charité shows how one university hospital hires. Indian doctors can read our post on Approbation from India.

A doctor who wants US training and pay?

The USA, accepting the Match odds and the visa uncertainty above. Johns Hopkins and Massachusetts General Hospital publish their stipends and visa positions.

How does Clunic help a doctor choose between the UK, Ireland, Germany and the USA?

Clunic is an independent licensing consultancy. It is not affiliated with the GMC, the Medical Council, any German authority or chamber, ECFMG, FSMB, NRMP or any employer, and it does not give immigration advice.

What does the free eligibility assessment check?

The free eligibility assessment reads your degree, internship, postgraduate qualifications, exam history and language results against each country's published routes, and tells you which doors are open now, which exam credits you already hold, and what is missing before you pay a non-refundable fee.

Where should you read next?

The country overviews for the UK, Ireland, Germany and the USA set out each system in full.

Evidence, 41 sources

Sources

Primary pages behind the figures above. Fees and rules change: read the source before acting on any summary of it.

  1. Residence Act, section 16d (opens in a new tab)

    Governmentgesetze-im-internet.de

Questions, 9 answered

Questions people ask

Question not covered? Tell us your profession and where you qualified, and ask for a free eligibility assessment.